Skip to main content

Amity & Sorrow by Peggy Riley

Amity & Sorrow
I loved Amity & Sorrow so much; I was caught up in the vivid and powerful story-telling. This is a book to treasure.

Amity and Sorrow are sisters, the children of First Wife Amaranth. Their father is a charismatic and manipulative leader of a cult preparing for the end of the world. He surrounds himself with adoring women - fifty wives and counting - who bear and care for his children while he tours the land looking for more converts. If you detect a hint of cynicism in my assessment of him, good. I hate him as much as I love this book. He collects damaged women, such as Amaranth, and co-opts them into his warped fantasy. The community is shut off from the outside world, the children raised with no education beyond his Word. Peggy Riley has created a character I can despise for all my days!

Amaranth has been in his thrall for too long, but even she has a breaking point. The danger to her children becomes immediate, so she flees, driving across the country until she drives straight into a tree. She is helped by Bradley, but it is a complicated situation. He is reluctant to get involved and the girls are frightened of him. He is no ready-made saviour. He's a decent man, but ill-equipped to deal with the problems confronting Amaranth and her children.

Possibly not as clueless as Amaranth though. I was so desperately frustrated by her at times. She knows she needs to make a new start, for her sake as well as Amity and Sorrow's, but it is so hard for her to change after so long. She clings to the first source of comfort available, Bradley, and seems to be still trapped in her need for a man to validate her life. She seeks approval and acceptance at the cost of taking her attention away from the children, who need her so much. Her timid attempts to escape the strictures of the cult rules do little to help Amity and, especially, Sorrow; they are confused and repelled by the changes.

Amity and Sorrow have grown up knowing no other way of life than their father's doctrine. As the eldest child Sorrow has been raised as an oracle. She monopolises everything, her will unopposed. Amity is left with the crumbs of attention - I wanted to hug that little girl, her neglect hangs heavy in my heart. The tension between the sisters is beautifully written, underscored with a menace that threatens to erupt at any moment.

The writing is beautiful throughout. I said at the beginning that it was vivid and some parts are perfectly clear in my mind. The euphoric, celebratory spinning the women do just bursts off the page. Peggy also uses names brilliantly; we can guess something about both Amity and Sorrow, but Amaranth too comes into her own. She can make things bloom from the barren place from which she starts. There is hope (and Hope). There are echoes of fertility and barrenness throughout the book, we're in dustbowl territory here. There is also a chilling conflation of father/Father. There are so many things to think about and discuss in the novel.

This book resonated with me in ways I find hard to put into words, but I can say that it has continued to play in my mind in the couple of weeks since I finished it. I think it's amazing.

I was very privileged to receive a review copy of Amity & Sorrow from Tinder Press. It is published in Hardback on 28 March 2013.


  1. Great review Sarah. I wanted to hug Amity too. I agree it's a story that stays in the mind, very thought provoking.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Interview With The Vampire: Claudia's Story by Anne Rice and Ashley Marie Witter

See What I Have Done by Sarah Schmidt

Lizzie Borden and the Borden Murders See What I Have Done by Sarah Schmidt

The story of Lizzie Borden has a whiff of folklore about it, it feels hazy to me, apocryphal perhaps, something half known and uncertain like Washington and the cherry tree or the ride of Paul Revere. Shamefully, I had to Google both the latter two examples to double check they were the events I thought I was referring to. I choose them deliberately though - is it my Englishness that makes these events fuzzy to me? Do these stories live in the American psyche the way Magna Carta, Henry VIII and his six wives, and Jack the Ripper (to select three almost at random) live in mine? 
I remember a book we stocked when I was a very young bookseller at Waterstones in Watford that looked at the psychology of children who murder their parents. The copy on the back of the book talked of Lizzie Borden. I remember half wondering about the case, then shelving the book away and moving onto the next armful. But it stuck in my m…

Super Special Summer Picnic Book Chase

My nieces and nephews and I have a monthly book club, called Book Chase (although it sometimes gains an extra 's' to become Book Chasse). The rules are simple: we all bring something we've read during the last month, talk about it to each other, and eat snacks. We live tweet each meeting with the hashtag BookChase. Sometimes, when we remember, we Storify all the tweets too. This month, we remembered!